VPN vs Firewall: Full 2025 Comparison & When You Actually Need Both

VPNs and firewalls are two completely different security tools, but people often confuse them because both “protect your connection.” In reality, they operate on different layers, solve different problems, and complement each other rather than compete.

This guide breaks down the exact differences, explains what each tool does, highlights limitations, and shows when using both is the smartest choice.

Get NordVPN — Strong Privacy Try Surfshark — Unlimited Devices

Quick Answer

What Is a VPN?

A VPN (Virtual Private Network) encrypts your entire internet connection and routes it through a secure server. This provides:

• IP masking — websites cannot see your real location;
• Traffic encryption — your ISP cannot monitor what you do online;
• Safe public Wi-Fi — critical when working in cafés or airports;
• Stable routing — can improve streaming or gaming paths.

If you’re new to VPNs, start with our foundation guide: What Is a VPN?

What Is a Firewall?

A firewall monitors and controls incoming and outgoing connections. It acts like a “gatekeeper” to your device or network. Firewalls can:

• Block suspicious inbound traffic (malware, probes, scans);
• Stop unauthorized outbound requests (rogue apps, spyware);
• Enforce security rules at the network or device level;
• Segment internal networks in business environments.

To better understand technical flow, check our article: How VPN Works.

VPN vs Firewall: Key Differences

Can You Use a VPN Without a Firewall?

Technically yes — but it’s not ideal. A VPN hides your identity and encrypts traffic, but it does not stop malware, phishing attempts, or suspicious inbound packets.

Can You Use a Firewall Without a VPN?

Many people do. Your device remains protected against network threats, but your traffic remains unencrypted, meaning:

• your ISP can monitor all online activity;
• your IP address stays visible;
• public Wi-Fi remains risky;
• you cannot bypass censorship or geo-blocks.

Should You Use Both?

Yes — this is the most secure combination. A VPN protects your privacy, while a firewall guards your device from harmful traffic.

For additional hardening, see our guide: VPN Security Basics.

Common Misconceptions

• “A VPN replaces a firewall.” False.
• “A firewall encrypts my traffic.” False.
• “VPN protects from viruses.” False — that’s antivirus/firewall territory.

Video Overview

Try NordVPN — Better Privacy Try Surfshark — Secure All Devices

FAQ

Does a VPN block viruses?

No. A VPN hides your IP and encrypts your traffic, but it does not block malware.

Does a firewall hide my IP?

No. A firewall filters traffic, but your IP remains visible unless you use a VPN.

What protects me on public Wi-Fi?

You need a VPN. A firewall alone is not enough for insecure hotspots.

Should I turn off Windows Firewall when using a VPN?

No. Both should stay enabled. They do not conflict.

Related Guides

• VPN Security Basics
• VPN Advantages
• VPN Encryption Explained
• VPN Not Connecting?

Conclusion

VPNs and firewalls work best together. One protects your privacy, the other protects your system from threats. In 2025 — with rising cyber attacks and ISP tracking — combining both is no longer optional but the baseline for safe digital life.

Written by Denys Shchur

Founder of SmartAdvisorOnline. I write clear, practical guides about VPNs, privacy and cybersecurity.